Spare Parts Know How

Spare Parts Inventory Management Training

  • Log-In
  • Individual
    • Practitioner Toolkit
    • Open Access
    • Compare Options
  • Organization/Team
    • Foundations for Teams
    • Enterprise Access
    • Foundations Playbook
    • Operations Playbook
    • Compare Options
  • Targeted Improvement Programs
    • Capability Programs
    • Advisory Support
    • Inventory Optimization Software
    • Data Management Services
  • Resources
    • The Spare Parts Decision Framework
    • Spare Parts Capability Playbooks
    • Roadmap for Spare Parts Decision Capability
    • Site Capability Assessment
    • Spare Parts Management Checklists
    • Obsolescence Risk Calculator
    • Criticality Assessment Tool
    • ROP/ROQ Calculator
    • Last Time Buy Calculator
    • Books
    • Practitioner Playbook Digital Library
  • Contact
  • About
    • Past and Current Users
    • Testimonials
    • FAQs
    • Phillip Slater

How do we determine spare parts criticality?

You are probably asking this because too many parts have been classified as critical, or because no one is confident that the current criticality ratings are accurate.

The reality is that not every important spare part is critical.

In fact, items that are critical for a machine to operate are not necessarily required as critical inventory.

This is counter-intuitive but also true.

And that distinction matters.

If everything is called critical, then the label stops being useful.

Criticality should help you make better decisions about stocking, review frequency, supplier management, maintenance support, and risk exposure.
 


The Common Mistake

 
The common mistake is allowing criticality to become an opinion.

In many organisations, parts are classified as critical because:

    the equipment is important,
    maintenance says the part is needed,
    the part has a long lead time,
    the part is expensive,
    the part has caused a problem before,
    no one wants to take the risk of saying it is not critical.

Each of these factors may be relevant, but none of them automatically makes the part critical.

A part is not critical simply because it is expensive.

Nor is it critical simply because it belongs to critical equipment.
 


What a Better Decision Requires

 
A better criticality decision separates consequence from emotion.

That means considering questions such as:

    What happens if the part fails and no spare is available?
    Does the failure stop production, reduce capacity, create a safety risk, or breach compliance?
    Is the item required to restore equipment function?
    Can the part be repaired, sourced quickly, substituted, or bypassed?
    Is the consequence based on current operating conditions?
    Is the classification consistent across similar parts and assets?

Criticality should be a decision input, not a label applied casually.

Used properly, it helps determine which parts deserve attention, which parts require stronger controls, and which parts may not need to be stocked at all.
 


Where This Is Covered

 
This topic is covered in the Foundations Playbook, which addresses not only why criticality matters and why it is often misunderstood, but also a comprehensive, yet easy to apply framework for determining criticality.

For individuals this playbook is available via the Practitioner Toolkit.

For teams, Foundations for Teams helps create a shared language so criticality is not driven by the loudest voice in the room.
 


Choose Your Next Step

 
Explore the Practitioner Toolkit
The complete spare parts management toolkit for practitioners.

Enquire about Foundations for Teams
Build a common decision language across the people who influence spare parts outcomes.
 

Practitioner Toolkit

Designed for professionals responsible for spare parts inventory management, the Toolkit combines calculators, decision tools, checklists, policy templates, specialist reports, and structured learning resources.
Learn more...

Team Alignment and Capability

Guided by our Foundations Playbook this facilitated online program helps your people develop common decision-making principles, understand their respective roles, and establish a stronger foundation for improving spare parts inventory performance. Explore Foundations for Teams...

Targeted Improvement Programs

A Targeted Improvement Program is a scoped program of work designed around the organization’s specific objectives. This may include inventory optimization, policy development, global standardization, or other operational goals. Explore Capability Programs...

Latest Blog Posts

  • Consistency Across Sites Does Not Mean Making the Same Decision
  • Digital Spare Parts Inventory: What It Is and What It Is Not
  • Why Spare Parts Inventory Optimization Doesn’t Stick
  • AI Spare Parts Technology Won’t Fix Weak Decisions
  • Twenty-Five Years of Better Spare Parts Decisions
  • Email
  • LinkedIn
  • YouTube

Copyright © 2026 IPIAIGHT PTY LTD.